Skip to content
Brian Ohebshalom

Why phone pouches fail, from a student who watched them fail

By , Co-founder & Co-CEO of LockedIn Technologies ·

I spent two years of high school handing my phone to a pouch every morning. So did everyone around me. And every day, some of my classmates got around it.

How students beat the pouch

The workarounds were not clever. Some students bought strong magnets online to pop the lock. Others put a dummy phone or an old device in the pouch and kept their real phone in their pocket. Some pouches just got broken.

Every workaround landed on a teacher. Is it in the pouch? Is it the real phone? When can it be unlocked? Teachers ended up policing phones period after period instead of teaching.

The problem is the design, not the students

Students are not uniquely bad at following rules. Phones are built to keep us engaged, and they are very good at it. A rule that depends on a teenager ignoring that pull every single period is a rule that will lose.

If there is a loophole, students will find it. I know because I sat in those classrooms.

Putting a phone away still leaves the temptation in your bag. Screen time limits can be turned off. Pouches and lockers cost money, need staff, and still get bypassed.

What a phone-free school actually needs

When I co-founded LockedIn in my senior year at Milken Community School, the goal was to build the opposite of a pouch. The phone stays in the student's pocket. It locks itself when the student arrives on campus during school hours, and it unlocks after the last bell.

That removes the decision. Nobody hands anything over, and no teacher has to check. When a student tries a workaround, like deleting the app or faking a location, the school's dashboard shows it by name.

It also fixes the safety problem pouches create. With LockedIn, students can always call 911 and their family, and in an emergency the school can reach every phone on campus with one tap.

The test I use

Any phone policy should pass a simple test: does it still work on a Tuesday in March, when nobody is watching? If it depends on constant enforcement, it will not. The policies that work change the environment. They do not ask for more willpower.